Although the same standard as the previous season was not achieved
in season 1966-67 (the Club could finish only ninth in the League) yet
another run to the Scottish Cup semi-final was achieved. United again
fell at the penultimate hurdle. This time Aberdeen were 1-0 winners
courtesy of an unlucky own goal by Tommy Millar in a game which perhaps
they should have won. The other domestic Cup yielded the usual disappointment
for Doug and his team mates but it had been a tough section. The most
memorable of Doug’s 48 games in all competitions that year must
surely be the tie against Spanish giants and Fairs Cup holders Barcelona.
United were victorious home and away and the reward for knocking out
the holders was a tie against Italian aces Juventus. Unfortunately the
Tannadice outfit went out despite a spirited win in the second leg at
home.
1966-67 was also the first time United participated in a lengthy close
season tour. They played in the North American Soccer League as Dallas
Tornados, beginning an association with then Dallas Tornados American
Football team owner Lamar Hunt, a connection which is maintained to
this day.
1967-68 was another disappointing season with Doug again an ever present
in the side. For the second season in a row United went out of the League
Cup in the group stages in another tough section. Whilst in the Scottish
Cup, after getting past St Mirren, the Terrors fought out an enthralling
game at Tanndice, eventually losing to Hearts by the odd goal in eleven!
During the League Cup run Doug netted his second goal for United in
a 2-2 draw against Aberdeen at Pittodrie.
The League campaign the following season saw an improvement in form.
United finished fifth to earn another crack at Europe. In the Scottish
Cup a promising start to the tournament was blighted by a poor home
defeat by Morton in the quarter-final. The League Cup was over before
it really began, after United lost their first three games in the group
stages, but then won the next three. For the first time in a while Doug
missed a game in the League Cup allowing a young Stewart Markland to
make his debut.
The Fairs Cup drew United a plumb tie against Newcastle United. The
English side was too good for United and they lost both home and away,
albeit narrowly. The League Cup and Scottish Cup brought more disappointment
for Doug, but at least the League position of fifth was again the outcome
of the campaign with Europe beckoning again. Doug also managed another
goal this term in a 5-4 win over Morton at home.
Until now all three of Doug’s goals were scored from open play
but all that was to change in 1970-71 when Doug became the recognised
penalty taker. In yet another season as an ever present he netted five
from the spot in the League and one in the League Cup. The season overall
was poor, with early exits from both domestic Cups and in Europe. A
League placing of sixth meant United lost out on Europe but instead
went into the Texaco Cup.
Doug’s goal tally increased again in 1971-72 as he scored two
more penalties. For the first season in his long career he was out of
the side through injury and missed nine League games in all. The Club
finished in mid table. In a lacklustre League Cup United again failed
to advance from the group stages, and in the Scottish Cup Aberdeen again
knocked the Terrors flying from the competition. In the Texaco Cup Doug
played in the 2-6 away defeat at Derby but missed the home leg.
An improvement in 1972-73 saw a sixth place finish again and Doug made
31 League appearances netting another five penalties. Three more spot
kicks were converted by Doug in the League Cup in which United at last
reached the quarter final stages only to be knocked out by Hibs. The
Scottish Cup ended in a 1-0 defeat at Ibrox. In the Texaco Cup, Doug
scored from a penalty in the 2-2 home draw against Leicester. United
drew 3-3 on aggregate and exited in a penalty shoot-out.
1973-74 may have been Doug’s finest season, although the League
campaign again saw only a mid table finish, with the centre half making
26 appearances and scoring three penalties. He netted another in the
League Cup as United’s interest in the tourney ended again in
the group stages. In the Texaco Cup Doug played in the ties against
Sheffield United and Leicester City to set up a semi-final against Newcastle
United. Doug did not turn out in either of the two legs as United fell
4-3 after extra time in the away leg of the tie.
In the Scottish Cup however, Doug proudly led his team mates to a Hampden
final against Celtic. En route he had netted twice from the spot, one
crucially in the semi-final replay against Hearts.
In season 1974-75 Doug’s appearances became fewer. He started
only twenty of the 34 League matches and came off the bench twice. He
managed only one penalty goal that season in a 5-0 demolition of Motherwell
in the first game of the season. It proved to be his last goal for United.
Doug also played in two of United’s three Scottish Cup ties and
turned out in all six games of yet another group stage League Cup exit.
However, Doug did manage to make his mark in yet another European competition
as he played in all four of the Cup Winners Cup ties. A fourth place
earned entry to the next season’s UEFA Cup in which Doug played
twice, once as a substitute. Three League Cup ties and seven in the
League was Doug’s tally for the season. On 31st January 1976 Doug
played in his last game for United, a 2-1 defeat at Celtic Park, although
he remained until the end of the season helping develop young talent
in the reserve side. In a mark of gratitude for his service to the Club
the Directors awarded him a Testimonial match. In front of 5,000 spectators
his Guest XI for the game included, Ron Yeats, Dennis Gillespie and
Jimmy Briggs along with Bobby Lennox of Celtic, Ally Donaldson of Dundee,
Joe Harper and Willie Miller of Aberdeen and Tommy McLean of Rangers.
It says much that opponents of this calibre were prepared to honour
Doug in this fashion.
Although he never attained national League or Cup silverware or international
honours, Doug Smith was never one to mourn what he had not attained.
He retired from the game with one major distinction which will likely
never be repeated by another Scottish player. In all of his eighteen
year playing career during which he turned out in 628 competitive matches
he was never once cautioned! The feat is all the more remarkable for
Doug being a central defender, a position which generally sees more
bookings than most. Rated the best uncapped player in Scotland at the
time Doug said of his career “I thoroughly enjoyed every minute
of it and only gave up the game when the years caught up on me. I certainly
have no regrets about being a one club man, though had I played in the
modern game with the way contracts are these days things might well
have been different” As a player Doug Smith was the perfect professional
and was totally committed to Dundee United during his long career and
fully deserves to be classed as ---- A Legend.